How United and City set up the worst Manchester derby ever

How are issues going at Manchester United?

Here is the primary sentence of a chunk written by ESPN’s Rob Dawson two weeks in the past: “Ruben Amorim says he’s planning to stay as Manchester United supervisor, however he has admitted he can not assure he’ll nonetheless be within the job after the worldwide break.”

He is nonetheless within the job — thanks, maybe, to a 97th-minute penalty from Bruno Fernandes to safe a 3-2 win … over Burnley … at Outdated Trafford. Sure, so bleak are the vibes {that a} last-second dwelling victory over the projected worst group within the league is considered as a possible turning level.

There was Amorim’s tactics board becoming a meme within the Carabao Cup shootout loss to fourth-tier Grimsby City. There was the opening week loss to an Arsenal aspect that by no means received out of first gear and barely even turned on the ignition. There was the 1-1 draw with Fulham because of a Rodrigo Muniz personal aim. There, nonetheless, have been zero Premier League begins for €76.5-million signing Benjamin Sesko.

And but, if you happen to have a look at the Premier League desk, you will discover that Manchester United aren’t even the worst group in their very own metropolis. No, they have 4 factors from three matches.

Manchester City? They’ve misplaced two out of three — one thing an eventual Premier League winner has performed solely as soon as within the historical past of the league.

After lacking nearly all of final season to a torn ACL, reigning Ballon d’Or winner Rodri is again for Man Metropolis — and he is saying stuff like this: “I am not Messi. I am not going to come back again and simply make the group win and win and win.”

When the 2 Manchester sides met again in April, they produced one of many worst video games of final season: a scoreless draw through which Metropolis did not try a shot over the ultimate 20 minutes and neither group created a single harmful probability. Whereas this Sunday’s match on the Etihad should not be as uncompetitive as that one, the schedule is catching the 2 sides at their lowest collective level because the Abu Dhabi takeover of Metropolis again in 2008.

So, forward of what may be the worst Manchester derby in current reminiscence, let’s check out how we received right here and why one aspect of town may be nearer to turning it round than the opposite.

– Top 50 most expensive transfers this summer by true cost
– Worst 2025 summer transfers, from Cunha to Isak
– Why Man United’s best player might be their biggest flaw

A quick, current historical past of Manchester Metropolis and Manchester United

Every thing it is advisable to know is someplace on this chart, which sketches out the points-per-game averages for each Manchester golf equipment over each 10-month stretch since 2008:

We’ll begin with Metropolis. The Abu Dhabi takeover occurs, and the road shoots straight up all through AGUEROOOOOOOO in 2012. Then issues stall out beneath supervisor Roberto Mancini earlier than bouncing again up beneath Manuel Pellegrini, after which falling again down till 2016, when Pep Guardiola arrives.

After that? An instantaneous enchancment to ranges reached solely by one different group within the historical past of the league. There is a fall-off in the course of the seasons wrapped across the top of COVID however then a bounce again as much as the three straight titles from 2022 by means of 2024.

Issues remained OK for a month or two at first of final season, and now the alarms within the room are going off. Whereas the 10-month factors common has been decrease at instances since 2008, it is decrease than it has been at any level since Guardiola’s first season.

play

Onuoha: Man Metropolis cannot afford to lose the Manchester derby

Nedum Onuoha emphasizes the significance of profitable the Manchester derby following a disappointing begin to the season for Manchester Metropolis.

With United, nicely, the 10-month factors common is decrease than it has been at any level since 2008 — and at any level because the Premier League started.

At first of our knowledge set, we’re at maybe the height of Sir Alex Ferguson’s tenure as supervisor. United received the Champions League in 2008 after which made it again to the finals in 2009 and 2011, the place they misplaced, each instances, to the present supervisor of Manchester Metropolis. United received the Premier League in every of these three seasons, too, however the 2011 title got here with simply 80 factors — tied for the fewest factors of any title-winner this century. That opened up room for Metropolis to steal the title in 2012 — just for United to signal a past-his-peak Robin van Persie, get one final world-class season from him, and win yet another title in Sir Alex’s last season.

After that, it is a good instance of how progress is not linear. From 2013 to at the moment, United’s per-game efficiency has gone from title-winning to under league-average: they’re profitable a full level fewer per sport, or about 40 factors — 40! — over a full season.

However there have been ups and downs on the way in which down. You had the rapid drop-off beneath David Moyes, after which just about the identical story with the following 4 managers, Louis van Gaal, Jose Mourinho, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, and Erik ten Hag: transient, rapid enchancment, however final decline.

And that brings us to at the moment, to Man United beneath Ruben Amorim. There’s been no enchancment — it has been downhill from Day One.

Why one Manchester membership is nearer to turning it round than the opposite

I’ve in contrast Manchester United to the Dallas Cowboys earlier than and sure, now, I am doing it once more.

The Cowboys are the most well-liked sports activities franchise in the most well-liked sport within the United States. It is truly inconceivable for them to be boring, as a result of if they’re boring, we deal with it as if it is some nationwide disaster: Why are the Dallas Cowboys so boring? In the meantime, the Indianapolis Colts can go about present in the identical stage of mediocrity — not so good, not so unhealthy — and no person cares.

See what I am getting at right here? The identical holds true for United, solely within the highlight of the most well-liked sport on this planet.

Now, it is somewhat completely different right here as a result of the large ranges of inequality in soccer make it so Man United’s mediocrity is a a lot larger institutional failure than the Cowboys profitable half of their video games. If Manchester United are usually not competing for the Premier League and the Champions League in most years, then one thing has gone terribly unsuitable. And sure, which means issues have been going terribly unsuitable for over a decade now.

However due to the recognition of each the Cowboys and Manchester United, it signifies that these groups nearly must exist at extremes, and which means the general public sentiment or the standard knowledge round these groups is nearly all the time unsuitable. The Cowboys traded arguably their finest participant, Micah Parsons, on the eve of the 2025 NFL season, the sky was falling, disband the franchise … after which they almost beat the defending Tremendous Bowl champs, the Philadelphia Eagles, on the street in Week 1.

play

Is Ruben Amorin nonetheless the proper man for Manchester United?

Janusz Michallik casts doubt over Ruben Amorim’s tenure at Manchester United to this point after their final minute win vs. newly promoted Burnley.

With Manchester United, we have tried to make them into title contenders beneath Jose Mourinho, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, and Erik ten Hag after only a handful of constructive outcomes. I do know as a result of I actually wrote about it a little over two years ago in a chunk titled, “No, Manchester United are usually not within the Premier League title race.” I received a number of indignant feedback about it — after which they misplaced, 7-0, to Liverpool only a few weeks later. They completed eighth the next season.

Nonetheless, I believe the other applies right here, too. When Manchester United are unhealthy, it is typically not as unhealthy because it appears. Like, probably, proper now.

Now, I am not suggesting that Manchester United are good or that Ruben Amorim is their savior. However the greatest situation for Man United thus far this season hasn’t been something greater than the type of variance we might count on to even out over the remainder of the season for every other membership on this planet.

By way of three matches, they’ve tried 58 photographs — 14 greater than anybody else within the league — and so they’ve generated probably the most anticipated targets:

The one drawback is that they’ve turned all of that into simply 4 precise targets, which places them tied with the likes of West Ham and Burnley for the eighth-best mark within the league.

Whereas it’s type of humorous that Man United signed two gamers — Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo — who massively outperformed their xG last season solely to right away undergo by means of a ending droop, this is not going to proceed. I am not going to defend the loss to Grimsby City, but when United end their possibilities in that one, then we in all probability by no means discuss it once more, both.

Now, United aren’t near difficult for titles — and their team-building approach isn’t going to help with that, both — however they completed in Fifteenth-place final season. Even with the ending droop, they’re already six spots higher by means of the primary three matches of this season. For a group that solely scored 44 targets final season, the assault already seems significantly better.

At Manchester Metropolis, although, the identical points from final season persist.

Metropolis allowed 1.2 targets per sport final season and 20 touches inside their very own penalty space — each considerably larger marks than in any of the earlier seven seasons. Each time they turned the ball over, it was a five-alarm hearth. They spent a bunch of cash this previous summer time, however none of it appeared involved with their most obvious weak spot: the getting old legs and restricted vary in the course of the sector.

New arrivals Rayan Cherki and Tijjani Reijnders are plus gamers in possession, however negatives with out the ball. Rayan Aït-Nouri is not a nasty defender, but it surely’s not like left-back defending was their situation final yr.

Positive sufficient, by means of three matches, Metropolis have allowed 1.3 targets per sport on 1.3 anticipated targets allowed per sport. And so they’ve conceded 22 touches inside their very own penalty space. What makes that much more regarding is that their schedule hasn’t been significantly tough — their opponents completed eighth, sixteenth, and seventeenth final season. It looks like they figured that Rodri would remedy all of their points, and Rodri himself is already suggesting that was a nasty thought.

Whereas supervisor Pep Guardiola has solved loads of tactical issues earlier than, we’re arising on a yr from when Rodri went down final season. Meaning a yr with out Guardiola determining how you can repair this tactical drawback.

Metropolis might nonetheless bounce again and reemerge as title contenders, however betting markets and projection systems now have their title odds in a distant third — a lot nearer to Chelsea in fourth than Liverpool and Arsenal up on the high. Just some weeks in the past, it was presupposed to be a three-team race.

As for United? The over-under totals from Sporting Index projected them at 59 factors to begin the season. Now, that quantity is as much as 60. All of that yelling and screaming, and nearly nothing has modified.