Dexter Lawrence trade: Bengals, Giants, NFL draft takeaways

Once I was placing collectively my trade tiers column over the summer season and itemizing all of the gamers who may land a first-round choose or extra through a deal, Dexter Lawrence II was the final minimize. The Giants defensive deal with was a preeminent power on the inside and coming off a nine-sack season, however there have been loads of protection sacks or secondary pressures factored into these totals, and Lawrence was already deep into his second contract, a degree at which groups across the league had grown reluctant to commerce first-round picks for even standout gamers.

Nicely, the sport has modified. We have seen organizations across the NFL set up and pay a brand new premium for veteran defensive linemen. Even leaving Micah Parsons‘ deal with the Packers apart, the Cowboys sent first- and second-round picks to the Jets for Quinnen Williams. The Ravens agreed to send two first-round picks to the Raiders for Maxx Crosby earlier than walking that deal back for damage causes.

Subscribe: ‘The Bill Barnwell Show’

And on Saturday evening, the Bengals stunningly grew to become the most recent crew to go excessive for a veteran lineman, sending the 10th pick to the Giants so as to add Lawrence to their line of defense. The 28-year-old Lawrence had reportedly sought a new deal with New York, however as soon as the 2 sides weren’t capable of finding widespread floor, the Giants pivoted to the commerce market.

What they acquired, frankly, is surprising. There is a motive that the reviews on social media from NFL insiders needed to embrace “straight up” to verify that there wasn’t a second-round choose or one thing else substantial heading again to Cincinnati as a part of this deal. This can be a huge return, one that will have appeared fully gorgeous to me a yr in the past, even on condition that Lawrence was coming off a greater season. If we take a look at the large takeaways from this commerce, I’ve to start out there.

Leap to a takeaway:
The trade paradigm has shifted
The league doesn’t like this draft
The Bengals see Lawrence as a game-changer
The Bengals want Burrow to be happy

1. The NFL’s commerce paradigm has formally shifted.

Lawrence is now the fourth outstanding defensive lineman to be included in a commerce for a first-round choose over the previous 9 months after Parsons, Williams and Crosby (whose deal admittedly did not come to fruition however nonetheless offers us a way of how he was valued). The Parsons commerce does not actually belong with the opposite three, on condition that he was a youthful participant who hadn’t even signed his second contract, not to mention performed by means of a part of that deal.

The Cowboys’ commerce for Williams is actually the second when what NFL groups had been keen to pay to amass star defensive linemen halfway by means of their second contracts shifted. It is unattainable to say whether or not the Williams commerce was the primary instance of that new world or whether or not it was the precise commerce that brought about costs to go up, but it surely generated a return that appeared out of line with what groups had been keen to surrender in alternate for gamers with this degree of expertise, in addition to put on and tear. Keep in mind that the Bengals hadn’t been in a position to land a first-round choose final offseason as they regarded to commerce Trey Hendrickson, who was coming off a 17.5-sack, first-team All-Professional season.

Lawrence did not land the Giants a primary and a second, or a pair of first-round picks, however he did land them one other top-10 choice. We see groups commerce away top-10 picks as they transfer up for rookie expertise or as a part of offers the place they’ve dealt away future first-rounders (and did not know the place their first-rounders would land), but it surely’s extremely uncommon to see NFL franchises commerce picks this excessive within the draft for particular person veterans.

How uncommon? We have seen a grand whole of two veterans traded for first-round picks that had been already assured to be within the high 10 since 2000. One was Randy Moss, who was dealt as a part of a deal for the seventh choose in 2005. The opposite was Russell Wilson, who was shipped to the Broncos for a package deal that included the ninth choice in 2022. Moss was a 28-year-old broad receiver with a Corridor of Fame résumé. Wilson was a quarterback who had reached 5 consecutive Professional Bowls. Lawrence is an excellent participant, however he is not a quarterback, and he isn’t on a Corridor of Fame monitor.

Organizations had been extra comfy buying and selling first-round picks or excessive alternatives for veteran gamers within the Nineteen Eighties and Nineties, however because the league went below the wage cap and subsequently launched the rookie scale in 2011, we noticed groups emphasize choose worth and youthful expertise. Entrance places of work grew extra considerate about participant ageing expectations and acknowledged the potential of touchdown gamers on cost-controlled offers for the primary 4 years of their NFL careers. They’ve continued to prioritize youth in free company, however NFL common managers are immediately extra open to buying and selling first-round picks for veterans.

Though some pointed towards the Rams of the previous decade as proof that these picks is likely to be overvalued within the context of current trades, that has at all times been shortsighted. The Rams had been usually buying and selling their first-round picks for younger, established stars getting into the primes of their careers — gamers comparable to Brandin Cooks, Jalen Ramsey and most just lately Trent McDuffie. They reportedly tried to send two first-round picks to the Panthers for Brian Burns. Les Snead made a big move up within the draft for Jared Goff.

The Rams’ solely exception was trading two first-round picks for Matthew Stafford. Quarterbacks are sometimes the exception.

There was a yr when the Dolphins and Raiders each traded first-round picks (plus extra) in offers for veteran broad receivers in Tyreek Hill and Davante Adams, respectively, however non-quarterbacks in the course of their second contracts within the age-28 vary hadn’t usually landed first-round picks, not to mention something on high of that. We have now seen three trades agreed to involving veterans on this vary alongside the line of defense over the previous 9 months, though one wasn’t executed due to a bodily (and the Lawrence commerce continues to be topic to at least one).

I am unsure it is a smart shift towards prioritizing what groups imagine to be recognized portions. The Moss and Wilson trades did not work out in any way. Williams performed effectively in Dallas however wasn’t in a position to flip across the Cowboys’ protection in any kind of significant manner in his first half-season. The Adams deal was a disappointment in Vegas, because the Raiders did not self-scout and thought they had been nearer than they really had been to rivalry. Hill was a incredible broad receiver for 2 years in Miami, however the Chiefs would really feel fairly proud of what they landed on the opposite aspect of the deal, most notably with McDuffie.

With that being stated, there’s nonetheless loads of time for the Williams commerce to play out. We’ll see what occurs with Lawrence, who now turns into the point of interest of the protection in Cincinnati. And there is additionally the truth of the place the league goes schematically. Defenses need to reside just like the 2025 Seahawks and so many Vic Fangio-influenced models over the previous decade. They need to keep out of their base personnel, maintain a nickel defender on the sector as a lot as doable, play two deep safeties, present mild packing containers when it comes to dimension and numbers, affect groups to run the ball after which repeatedly win towards offenses by stealing gaps and profitable their one-on-one matchups. You might want to have standouts up entrance to make that work, and there aren’t many people on the planet who’ve Lawrence’s mixture of dimension and athleticism.

Though I personally may not assume buying and selling first-round picks for gamers approaching 30 is a good concept, it is clear that NFL groups are extra open to the thought than they’ve been in years previous. That is going to affect the commerce market at premium positions within the years to come back. The return the Panthers finally landed for Burns (a second-round choose and a pair of fifth-rounders) feels mild compared to what is going on round now. The Eagles should not accept something wanting a first-round choose for A.J. Brown. And if a participant like Jeffery Simmons ever landed in commerce talks, effectively, we might be taking a look at an NBA-esque haul for one of many league’s finest defensive gamers, even on condition that he is turning 29 in July. I will have to include that shifting ahead as I consider these trades.

2. The league does not seem to love this draft class.

An alternate clarification for what is going on on may merely be that the NFL does not see 2026 first-round picks as notably invaluable. Though there are a number of standout hybrid gamers on the high of the primary spherical and a few positions which are comparatively deep into Day 2, that is broadly regarded across the league as one of many weaker drafts in current reminiscence.

Organizations need to see drafts with plug-and-play starters at key positions like broad receiver, edge rusher and left deal with, however there aren’t many gamers who mission to be standouts in these spots. The gamers who will come off the board first at these positions have extra query marks than ordinary. Is Texas Tech’s David Bailey stout sufficient to carry up as an NFL edge defender? Is Ohio State’s Arvell Reese actually an elite cross rusher? Is OSU’s Carnell Tate a real WR1 or a participant who benefited from enjoying throughout from Jeremiah Smith?

I feel the solutions to all three of these questions are sure, but it surely’s simpler to say that from the surface than it’s to place a first-round choose behind that decision. And given how we have now seen the Packers, Colts, Bengals, Rams and even the Ravens (briefly) commerce away first-round picks for veteran gamers over the previous few months, it definitely looks like there are groups that do not see this as a premium draft. The Cowboys, on the contrary, traded away a 2027 first-round choose and held on to their two first-rounders in 2026 as a part of the Williams deal.

All of that might make for a captivating draft this upcoming week. Will groups just like the Titans which may need to transfer down battle to seek out commerce companions? Will veterans be on the transfer come draft evening if groups with small boards do not land the participant they need? Or as Chiefs common supervisor Brett Veach suggested, will there be quite a lot of trades from groups that see solely a handful of gamers they actually need and exit of their manner to ensure they land these valuable few standouts?

3. The Bengals imagine Lawrence is a real game-changer.

With the tenth choose, the Bengals might need been in place to draft somebody like Miami edge rusher Rueben Bain Jr. or LSU cornerback Mansoor Delane, gamers who charge among the many finest at their respective positions on this class. With historical past telling us how the league views safeties, Ohio State’s Caleb Downs might need even fallen to them. Except the draft went in fully surprising methods, the Bengals had been going to be in place to take a defensive participant who would have excited their fan base in Spherical 1.

As an alternative, they traded for Lawrence, touchdown the Bengals a three-time Professional Bowler on the inside. Evaluating Lawrence’s affect, particularly after final season, is hard. Let’s begin with the passing recreation. Most nostril tackles haven’t got the athletic potential or the time to affect the quarterback. Lawrence is among the few exceptions to that rule, as he is able to overwhelming inside linemen one-on-one and profitable rapidly sufficient to truly trigger opposing passers some issues.

Lawrence’s nine-sack season in 2024 is an outlier, and on nearer inspection on the time, a handful of these takedowns had been cleanup sacks on performs the place another person gained and Lawrence benefited. The 2025 season was a case of regression well beyond the imply, as Lawrence fell all the way in which to 0.5 sacks. His stress charge fell from 9.6% in 2024 to five.9% in 2025, per NFL Subsequent Gen Stats.

Each 2024 and 2025 appear to be unrealistic expectations for Lawrence’s sack manufacturing or lack thereof. He has averaged 5 sacks and 16 knockdowns per 17 video games as a professional, and people numbers appear eminently cheap as a projection for Lawrence’s 2026 marketing campaign.

That kind of pass-rush manufacturing from a 0-technique defensive deal with is great, and it will make life simpler for Cincinnati’s edge rushers, who will not see double-teams fairly as usually. But when Lawrence is your finest cross rusher, as he tasks to be for a Bengals crew that did not have a participant high six sacks final season, I am unsure you are going to have the kind of cross rush you are hoping for out of your entrance 4.

play

Bengals purchase Dexter Lawrence

Ben Child breaks down the Bengals’ resolution to commerce the tenth total choose for Dexter Lawrence.

The identical qualities that make Lawrence so explosive as an inside cross rusher additionally make him a load to take care of within the run recreation. He is not going to shoot gaps and make quite a lot of tackles for loss within the backfield towards the run, having maxed out at 4 in a single season since becoming a member of the Giants, however he will soak up double-teams and create alternatives for different gamers to stream to the ball provider. Lawrence was double-teamed on the second-highest charge of any inside lineman within the league final season.

Even with a full season from a participant avowed to be the most effective nostril deal with in soccer, although, the Giants had been horrific towards the run in 2025. They had been final within the league in EPA per play towards designed runs (plus-0.13), final in yards per carry allowed towards these rush makes an attempt (5.4) and thirty first in success charge allowed (51.7%). They gave up constant chunks of yardage, received pushed off the road after which allowed too many large performs as soon as operating backs received previous the primary degree.

I do not assume anybody can or ought to pin nearly all of these points on Lawrence. The Giants misplaced beginning linebacker Micah McFadden to a season-ending injury in Week 1, although he is not precisely Fred Warner. They did not have nice gamers within the secondary. The tackling and the angles merely weren’t adequate. However on the similar time, watch sufficient of these large performs and you may see a few the place Lawrence gets blocked out of the play one-on-one. It wasn’t his finest season as a run defender, owing maybe to a balky elbow.

In the event you’re a Bengals fan who needs to jot down off 2025 as a misplaced season for Lawrence given the damage, his frustrations along with his contract and a New York crew that fired its coach at midseason and was out of the postseason image by mid-November, that is completely cheap. However though the Bengals have made adjustments on the again finish to attempt to repair a few of their issues this offseason, this crew had the identical points with tackling and angles that the Giants had. Cincinnati led the league with 170 missed tackles final season. No different crew had more than 131. Swapping out Geno Stone for Bryan Cook was a significant tackling improve, and Boye Mafe might be an improve on the sting, however this wasn’t a crew that regarded prefer it was one superb defensive deal with away from stopping the run in 2025.

It is also honest to say that Lawrence did not have an ideal yr as the most effective participant on a really unhealthy protection. And now, the Bengals are paying a premium to make Lawrence the most effective participant on what has been a really unhealthy protection in Cincinnati within the hopes that he’ll flip it round. That very same transfer failed to show across the Cowboys with Williams.

And that premium goes to value the Bengals. ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported that Lawrence is receiving a one-year, $28 million extension as a part of this commerce. He has two years and $42 million remaining on his current deal, and it would not be a shock if the Bengals assured some or all of that current cash as a part of this commerce. At three years and $70 million, Lawrence’s $23.3 million common wage would make him one of many highest-paid defensive tackles within the league, though he would not come near matching what Chris Jones earns on his take care of the Chiefs. All of this assumes that the Bengals will not negotiate a brand new take care of Lawrence after the yr.

In the event you throw within the opportunity cost of buying and selling away the tenth choose and the prospect of including a younger, difference-making defender on a rookie deal for 4 years, that provides one other $10.6 million per yr to the Lawrence commerce’s price ticket. Issue that implied value in, and Lawrence may find yourself being a $34 million-per-year participant, which places him proper alongside Jones’ deal and makes something wanting superstardom a disappointment.

After all, each Bengals followers and executives may wonder if there have ever been difference-makers within the draft for them on protection. Within the early days of the Joe Burrow period, the Bengals spent closely on protection in free company and constructed their offense by means of the draft. As these offensive standouts earned second contracts and re-signing them received costlier, Tobin’s plan was to rebuild the protection by means of the draft, simply as Howie Roseman has executed lately with the Eagles.

These picks have largely been disastrous. The Bengals have used 10 top-100 picks on defenders since their 2021 run to the Tremendous Bowl. The one surefire hit has been cornerback DJ Turner II. Dax Hill has been strong when wholesome, and the jury continues to be out on their 2025 picks, however gamers comparable to Cam Taylor-Britt, Zachary Carter and Kris Jenkins Jr. have been main disappointments. If the Bengals had nailed any of their defensive deal with picks, they would not be buying and selling for Lawrence as we speak.

You’ll be able to perceive why the Bengals really feel determined. They’ve continued to commit assets within the draft to their entrance seven with disappointing outcomes. They fired defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo and changed him with Al Golden, however that did not repair Cincinnati’s issues. They did not have Hendrickson for many of 2025, and he left for the Ravens in free company final month. The cash which may have gone to Hendrickson went to Mafe and Prepare dinner as an alternative, and now, they’re taking over one other giant contract by buying and selling for Lawrence. They’re determined as a result of they need to win, in fact, however there’s one other occasion in addition they need to please.

4. The Bengals need Burrow to be blissful.

This is not the NBA. It is rather more troublesome for gamers to power their manner out of conditions that are not tenable or fulfilling within the NFL. And Bengals followers who noticed their crew land on a wildly profitable and charismatic quarterback with the primary choose understandably do not need to even broach the concept that their market is just a few stopover level earlier than Burrow strikes on to brighter lights in an even bigger metropolis.

And but, there is a motive commerce discuss swirls round Burrow however not round Josh Allen in Buffalo or Patrick Mahomes in Kansas Metropolis, neither of whom is in one of many league’s largest or most outstanding media markets. The Bengals haven’t been in a position to persistently encompass Burrow with what he must win. Though they did get offers executed with Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins, Burrow’s high two receivers, the protection merely hasn’t been adequate. Burrow performed MVP-caliber soccer in 2024 and had probably the greatest seasons ever by an NFL quarterback who missed the postseason. He handled accidents in 2023 and 2025, and the Bengals went 5-11 within the video games Burrow missed these years.

The Bengals have a notion of being notably low cost, however I am unsure that is actually borne out when it comes to on-field spending. Between 2022 and 2025, they had been twenty second within the league in money spending, forward of groups just like the Seahawks (thirtieth) and Rams (thirty second). They mission to be eighth in cash spent this year, a determine that ought to rise even larger if Lawrence indicators a take care of an enormous signing bonus. Their funding off the sector, notably in scouting, may nonetheless lag behind the remainder of the league, however there is a aggressive amount of money being poured into the roster itself.

Final yr, Burrow regarded enviously towards the Eagles and suggested that Philadelphia “pays everybody.” Though that is not actually true, you possibly can perceive why Burrow would take a look at different organizations and see them paying for a quarterback, a standout receiver or two, and difference-makers on each side of the soccer.

No one can accuse the Bengals of being low cost in making this commerce for Lawrence. I am simply unsure it is the most effective use of their assets, even when the previous Giants deal with is prone to ship a greater protection in 2026 than whomever the Bengals had been going to take at No. 10. I wonder if signing Hendrickson when he wished a brand new deal, utilizing a first-round choose on a defensive deal with a yr in the past and holding on to this 2026 first-rounder would have been cheaper and returned a greater protection within the course of.

There’s one other Burrow quote I maintain coming again to, although: “The [Super Bowl] window’s my complete profession.” Burrow stated that getting into the 2022 playoffs. He hasn’t been again to the postseason since. Regardless of the Bengals have executed to attempt to repair their issues or plug their holes over that time-frame has usually made issues worse. This can be a win-now transfer from a crew that has a participant who thinks he can win yearly.

If it does not work, I wonder if there’s anything the Bengals will have the ability to do to persuade Burrow that he is in the fitting place to win on an annual foundation. And if Burrow fully loses religion within the group, effectively, we have seen how that is gone earlier than in Cincinnati.